forthcoming>>

ECONOMIC POLICY EVALUATION

In addition to their regular forecasts for the major economic indicators, (in February for Latin American Consensus Forecasts and in July for the Consensus Forecasts and Asia Pacific Consensus Forecasts countries) we survey our panelists for their qualitative evaluations of economic policy. The data below sets out the consensus responses for two of the larger Latin American economies. The balance between current monetary and fiscal policy is assessed, as are panelists' views regarding the likely and recommended direction of policy over the next twelve months.


Consensus Forecasts Asia Pacific
Consensus Forecasts
Latin American
Consensus Forecasts
United States Australia Argentina
Japan China Brazil
Germany Hong Kong Chile
France India Mexico
United Kingdom Indonesia Venezuela
Italy Malaysia Colombia
Canada New Zealand Peru
Netherlands Philippines  
Norway Singapore  
Spain South Korea  
Sweden Taiwan  
Switzerland Thailand  

Our survey for Economic Policy Evaluation covers each of the countries listed above. For illustrative purposes we have included forecast tables for Brazil and Mexico, along with a small portion of the text commentary taken from our February 2010 survey below. To view a sample issue of Latin American Consensus Forecasts please click the "Download Sample Issues" button below

Download Sample Issues


In Brazil - Percentage of respondents believing:
Current Too Restrictive About Right Too Stimulative
 Monetary Policy is 0 82 18
 Fiscal Policy is 0 9 91
Future 1 More Restrictive Left Unchanged More Stimulative
 Monetary Policy will be 91 9 0
 Monetary Policy should be 91 9 0
 Fiscal Policy will be 27 55 18
 Fiscal Policy should be 100 0 0

1 Relates to monetary and fiscal policy over the next twelve months.

In Brazil, the benchmark SELIC rate has been slashed to 8.75% as the authorities sought to prop up the economy in the face of headwinds from the global credit crisis. In addition, the government stepped up spending, offering tax breaks on cars and white goods. The measures had the desired effect and Brazil was able to emerge from recession at a much quicker rate than many developed nations. With the economy firmly on a recovery path, the central bank’s rate cutting cycle looks to have troughed. Indeed, over 90% of respondents take the view that monetary policy will and should be tightened over the next 12 months. A similar group believes that current fiscal policy is too stimulative, with the entire panel supporting tighter measures over the next year.


In Mexico- Percentage of respondents believing:
Current Too Restrictive About Right Too Stimulative
 Monetary Policy is 0 71 29
 Fiscal Policy is 43 57 0
Future 1 More Restrictive Left Unchanged More Stimulative
 Monetary Policy will be 64 36 0
 Monetary Policy should be 43 57 0
 Fiscal Policy will be7 79 14
 Fiscal Policy should be 0 50 50

1 Relates to monetary and fiscal policy over the next twelve months.

With last year’s US recession having pulled Mexican GDP deep into negative territory, policy has become even more important in navigating the downturn and laying the groundwork for the recovery. The central bank, in particular, has been viewed favourably, with 71% judging current policy about right. Looking ahead, 64% of our panel predict that policy will tighten, although the depth of the recession has been such that 57% would rather interest rates stayed unchanged. Still, 43% support Banxico’s forthcoming policy direction. The fiscal outlook has our panel more divided with the emergence of massive public deficits (see chart, above). Our respondents are bracing themselves for higher taxes over the coming year while also putting the spotlight on the lack of structural reforms in the economy.

A portion of text from Latin American Consensus Forecasts, February 15, 2010